Welcome to Simp McGhee's
Simp McGhee's, located at 725 Bank St, Decatur, AL, offers a delightful dining experience that blends upscale culinary creativity with a relaxed atmosphere. Known for its flavorful Cajun cuisine, the menu highlights include the pecan-crusted trout and the unforgettable DEANS DELIGHT — a prime rib dish complemented by gulf shrimp and bowtie pasta in a Cajun cream sauce. Patrons appreciate the attentive service and the staff's commitment to gluten-free practices, ensuring an inclusive dining experience. The restaurant's historic setting, with options for upstairs dining and outdoor seating, adds to the charm, making it a must-visit for both locals and travelers alike.
-
725 Bank St, Decatur, AL 35601, United States Hotline: +1 256-353-6284
If you find yourself wandering the charming streets of Decatur, Alabama, a meal at Simp McGhee's promises to be a delightful highlight of your culinary journey. Nestled at 725 Bank St, this quaint eatery beckons with its warm ambiance and a distinctive New Orleans flair, setting the perfect stage for both casual diners and special occasions.
As you step inside, the nostalgia washes over you—a vintage vibe enveloped in cozy seating, hardwood tables, and a welcoming atmosphere that feels just like home. Patrons rave about the attentive service, with friendly staff members who are well-versed in accommodating diverse dietary needs, including gluten-free options. It's no wonder that Lisa McCollum describes her experience as "nice," highlighting the pecan-crusted trout and peach fried pie as memorable dishes that transport you straight to flavor town.
For those seeking a taste of the South, the reviews sparkle with praise for the Cajun-inspired offerings. Nate Griffie hails the upscale yet relaxed dining experience, with standout dishes like shrimp and grits and perfectly cooked steaks—cooked to perfection, as Wes Watson would say. The flavor profiles run rich and bold, sure to satisfy any discerning palate.
Another must-try is the Deep Fried Green Beans, which Timmy Price declares "amazing," especially when paired with their enticing dipping sauce. For a truly unforgettable experience, don't skimp on the steak known as Dean's Delight. With a tantalizing Cajun cream sauce accompanying prime cuts and Gulf shrimp, it's a dish that leaves you speechless—your taste buds in a state of bliss!
Whether you decide to dine upstairs for charming views or settle into the bar downstairs, Simp McGhee's is a testament to what fine dining can be—great food served at reasonable prices, all wrapped in exceptional service. So, if you’re ever in the area, take a moment to indulge in what Robert Gilreath aptly describes as "dinner perfection." You'll leave not just satisfied, but eager to return for more delectable dishes and heartfelt hospitality.
Nice experience! Came on a Tuesday evening and enjoyed the quiet weeknight vibe. Staff is nice, food very good. Enjoyed the pecan crusted trout and peach fried pie!
Service was very attentive. Food was very good. Staff is aware of celiac disease and gluten-free safety and practices. Gluten-free pizza appetizer was so good. My non-celiac friend loved it as well. Said he couldn't tell that it was gluten-free.
Everything was cooked to perfection, best stuffed mushrooms I've ever had. A little disappointed they didn't have bread.
Dinner experience, from start to finish was as fine as it gets. All of it was perfect. Sit upstairs if possible...
Much Wow! Walked in and was taken back a couple decades by the feel of the place. We were seated by the wall on an old hardwood table. The first thing I noticed, as two big men were seated there.... The table.... It didn't WOBBLE... At all. VERY odd. Almost old horror movie type disturbing... You'd expect it to wobble, and it didn't. We looked around, as of we were going to be murdered.. Jk. We got an appetizer, Deep fried Green Beans. Amazing (the dipping sauce, much wow, get extra!)! We knew already what we wanted as I'd seen it described in a prior review of the joint. DEANS DELIGHT! It was scary for me to order, because it didn't say the price of it, only stated "Market Value". When I ordered the waitress said, how do you want your steak... Which I replied to, "It's Prime Rib, didn't think it mattered..." . Then she laid the big one on me... I don't know why they put that on there, it's a filet (It came out like a Big Chunk of Meat!)... In my mind, holy heck how expensive is this thing?!? Still ordered it, my friend did as well. I'll finish with saying, I cannot describe to you the tastes of the dish, as my tongue had no idea what to do or how to read it, but it was nothing short of out of this world!!! With that said, you'd be a fool to order anything else. The filet, perfect. The gulf shrimp, perfect. And the filler, bowtie pasta in a Cajun cream sauce... Even better. You will not be letdown. Oh, and back to the market value thing, the meal was 40 dollhairs at the time of this post. We left, fat and sassy. AND, I will go back again whenever in the area!
Excellent food and great service. Good shrimp and grits and steaks. We came in town for a concert and this was the perfect dinner before the show! Highly recommend.
Cajun food is amazing. It says upscale but you don’t have to dress fancy. Reasonable prices and the quality and taste is worth every dollar!
Wonderful New Orleans themed dinner location in downtown Decatur. Beautiful historic building with nice views, upstairs dining, downstairs bar and some outside seating. Prices are reflected by the selection and quality selection. Great attentive service and friendly staff. We ordered steak which was delicious and a couple appetizers- also delicious!!